--- title: "Kraft v Bega: Trade Dress Dispute Over Peanut Butter | FAL IP Lawyers" description: FAL IP analyses Kraft v Bega, highlighting the importance of goodwill in unregistered trade marks and lessons for IP transactions. Learn more at FAL IP. --- [![This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png?width=200&height=67&name=This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png "This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers")](https://www.fal-ip.com.au) [![This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png?width=938&height=313&name=This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png "This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers")](https://www.fal-ip.com.au) [Call Us 03 9642 2272](tel:0396422272) - [Home](https://fal-ip.com.au) - [Services](https://fal-ip.com.au/services) - [Trade Marks](https://fal-ip.com.au/trademarks) - [Designs](https://fal-ip.com.au/designs) - [Patents](https://fal-ip.com.au/patents) - [IP Legal](https://fal-ip.com.au/ip-legal) - [Industries](https://fal-ip.com.au/industries) - [Construction](https://fal-ip.com.au/construction) - [Food and Farming](https://fal-ip.com.au/food-and-farming) - [Manufacturing Technologies](https://fal-ip.com.au/manufacturing-technologies-and-consumer-products) - [Medical Devices](https://fal-ip.com.au/medical-devices) - [Resources and Mining](https://fal-ip.com.au/resources-and-mining-technology) - About Us - [Peter Francis](https://fal-ip.com.au/peter-francis) - [Rhys Munzel](https://fal-ip.com.au/rhys-munzel) - [Sarah Moorfoot](https://fal-ip.com.au/sarah-moorfoot) - [Latest News - Intellectual Property News Australia](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog-1) - [Payments](https://fal-ip.com.au/payments-pay-your-invoice-online-to-fal-ip) - [Contact](https://fal-ip.com.au/contact) - [Call Us Now](tel:+61396422252) search - There are no suggestions because the search field is empty. [![This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png?width=200&height=67&name=This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png "This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers")](https://www.fal-ip.com.au) - [Home](https://fal-ip.com.au) - [Services](https://fal-ip.com.au/services) - [Trade Marks](https://fal-ip.com.au/trademarks) - [Designs](https://fal-ip.com.au/designs) - [Patents](https://fal-ip.com.au/patents) - [IP Legal](https://fal-ip.com.au/ip-legal) - [Industries](https://fal-ip.com.au/industries) - [Construction](https://fal-ip.com.au/construction) - [Food and Farming](https://fal-ip.com.au/food-and-farming) - [Manufacturing Technologies](https://fal-ip.com.au/manufacturing-technologies-and-consumer-products) - [Medical Devices](https://fal-ip.com.au/medical-devices) - [Resources and Mining](https://fal-ip.com.au/resources-and-mining-technology) - About Us - [Peter Francis](https://fal-ip.com.au/peter-francis) - [Rhys Munzel](https://fal-ip.com.au/rhys-munzel) - [Sarah Moorfoot](https://fal-ip.com.au/sarah-moorfoot) - [Latest News - Intellectual Property News Australia](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog-1) - [Payments](https://fal-ip.com.au/payments-pay-your-invoice-online-to-fal-ip) - [Contact](https://fal-ip.com.au/contact) - [Call Us Now](tel:+61396422252) ## [![This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png?width=938&height=313&name=This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png "This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers")](https://www.fal-ip.com.au) [Call Us 03 9642 2272](tel:0396422272) [✕](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/a-nutty-trade-mark-dispute-kraft-v-bega#atbs-offcanvas-primary) - [Home](https://fal-ip.com.au) - [Services](https://fal-ip.com.au/services) - [Trade Marks](https://fal-ip.com.au/trademarks) - [Designs](https://fal-ip.com.au/designs) - [Patents](https://fal-ip.com.au/patents) - [IP Legal](https://fal-ip.com.au/ip-legal) - [Industries](https://fal-ip.com.au/industries) - [Construction](https://fal-ip.com.au/construction) - [Food and Farming](https://fal-ip.com.au/food-and-farming) - [Manufacturing Technologies](https://fal-ip.com.au/manufacturing-technologies-and-consumer-products) - [Medical Devices](https://fal-ip.com.au/medical-devices) - [Resources and Mining](https://fal-ip.com.au/resources-and-mining-technology) - About Us - [Peter Francis](https://fal-ip.com.au/peter-francis) - [Rhys Munzel](https://fal-ip.com.au/rhys-munzel) - [Sarah Moorfoot](https://fal-ip.com.au/sarah-moorfoot) - [Latest News - Intellectual Property News Australia](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog-1) - [Payments](https://fal-ip.com.au/payments-pay-your-invoice-online-to-fal-ip) - [Contact](https://fal-ip.com.au/contact) - [Call Us Now](tel:+61396422252) Share - - - [Trade Marks](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/tag/trade-marks) # A Nutty Trade Mark Dispute: Kraft v Bega Posted on 16 Jun 2020 0 The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia unanimously dismissed Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC’s (**Kraft**) appeal of a decision entitling Bega Cheese Limited (**Bega**) to exclusive use of the distinctive trade dress or ‘get up’, consisting of ‘a jar with yellow lid, yellow label, blue or red peanut device (logo) and having a brown appearance when filled’ (**Peanut Butter Trade Dress**).\[1\] A comparison of the products can be shown below. ![](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/peanut-butter.png?width=595&height=199&name=peanut-butter.png) ## Background In 2017, Bega acquired the “peanut butter business” and related assets and goodwill of Kraft’s Australian subsidiary Mondelez Australia (Foods) Ltd (**Mondelez**), including the Peanut Butter Trade Dress. Following the acquisition, Bega began selling Bega-branded peanut butter products using the elements of the Peanut Butter Trade Dress. Soon after, Kraft began to manufacture and sell a peanut butter product in Australia, also using elements of the Peanut Butter Trade Dress, under the brand “The Good Nut”. Both Bega and Kraft argued that the other’s use of the Peanut Butter Trade Dress constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under Australian Consumer Law.\[2\] Other causes of action included breach of contract and passing off. Last year, the Federal Court at first instance determined because the Peanut Butter Trade Dress was inseparable from the goodwill of the business – it could only be assigned with the assignment of the rest of the peanut butter business. As such, Bega had exclusive use of the Peanut Butter Trade Dress when they purchased the iconic product. ## The Appeal In dismissing Kraft’s appeal, the Full Court confirmed the primary judge’s interpretation that, under Australian law, an unregistered trade mark may only be assigned together with the goodwill of the underlying business of which the trade mark is used. The Full Court’s decision can be found [here](http://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/cth/FCAFC/2020/65.html). ## Practical takeaways There are a number of lessons that come out of the Full Court’s judgment: - registered and unregistered trade marks can be an important source of goodwill of a business; - goodwill in an unregistered trade mark is inseparable from the business using it. Therefore, an unregistered trade mark in Australia may only be assigned with an assignment of the goodwill of the business in respect of which the trade mark was used; - registration of intellectual property rights, including trade dress or get up that is commercially valuable, is imperative to enforce your rights in the marks against others; - ensure that all licenses clearly state ownership and the scope of each parties’ right to use the intellectual property; and - conduct due diligence when selling your assets – ensure that the transaction documents clearly set out which intellectual property rights will be sold with the business. ## It’s NUT over: Appeal to the High Court It was recently announced that Kraft has filed an application in the High Court seeking special leave to appeal the Full Court’s decision. ## Need assistance? Our Intellectual Property team is well-placed to assist Australian businesses in protecting their intellectual property. If you have any queries about this article or trade marks generally, please get in touch. *The information contained in this document is not legal advice. It sets out matters of general opinion and should not be applied to your particular circumstances without obtaining specific legal advice as to your position, rights and obligations.* \[1\] *Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC v Bega Cheese Limited* \[2020\] FCAFC 65. \[2\] The Australian Consumer Law is contained in Schedule 2 of the *Competition and Consumer Act 2010* (Cth).   ![Michelle Wilson](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/@marketplace/ATBS/Interia/images/grayscale-mountain.png?width=180&height=180&name=grayscale-mountain.png) [Michelle Wilson](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/author/michelle-wilson) Learn more about Michelle Wilson. - [Trade Marks](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/tag/trade-marks) [0](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/a-nutty-trade-mark-dispute-kraft-v-bega#comments) [Previous](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/us-space-force) ### [Pew Pew Pew: U.S. Space Force Losing a Trade Mark Battle with a TV Show](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/us-space-force) [Next](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/victoria-beckham-is-in-a-vb-trade-mark-dispute-in-australia) ### [Victoria Beckham is in a “VB” Trade Mark Dispute in Australia](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/victoria-beckham-is-in-a-vb-trade-mark-dispute-in-australia) #### RELATED NEWS ### [Victoria Beckham is in a “VB” Trade Mark Dispute in Australia](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/victoria-beckham-is-in-a-vb-trade-mark-dispute-in-australia) Explore Victoria Beckham's legal challenge against VB Skinlab over the 'VB' trademark, highlighting... By [Michelle Wilson](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/author/michelle-wilson) Jun 5 2020 ### [Pew Pew Pew: U.S. Space Force Losing a Trade Mark Battle with a TV Show](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/us-space-force) FAL IP covers the U.S. Space Force trademark fight with Netflix, showing how first use matters in... By [FAL IP](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/author/fal-ip) Jul 20 2020 ### [TikTok, Parkinson’s Disease and a good-news story of Collaborative Innovation](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/tiktok-parkinsons-disease-and-a-good-news-story-of-collaborative-innovation) FAL IP explores TikTok users’ collaboration to design a pill bottle aiding Parkinson’s patients... By [Michelle Wilson](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/author/michelle-wilson) Jan 22 2021 [![This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png?width=938&height=313&name=This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png "This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers")](https://www.fal-ip.com.au) [![This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers](https://fal-ip.com.au/hs-fs/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png?width=938&height=313&name=This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png "This is an image of the FAL IP logo by FAL Lawyers")](https://www.fal-ip.com.au) - [Home](https://fal-ip.com.au) - [Services](https://fal-ip.com.au/services) - [Trade Marks](https://fal-ip.com.au/trademarks) - [Designs](https://fal-ip.com.au/designs) - [Patents](https://fal-ip.com.au/patents) - [IP Legal](https://fal-ip.com.au/ip-legal) - [Industries](https://fal-ip.com.au/industries) - [Construction](https://fal-ip.com.au/construction) - [Food and Farming](https://fal-ip.com.au/food-and-farming) - [Manufacturing Technologies](https://fal-ip.com.au/manufacturing-technologies-and-consumer-products) - [Medical Devices](https://fal-ip.com.au/medical-devices) - [Resources and Mining](https://fal-ip.com.au/resources-and-mining-technology) - About Us - [Peter Francis](https://fal-ip.com.au/peter-francis) - [Rhys Munzel](https://fal-ip.com.au/rhys-munzel) - [Sarah Moorfoot](https://fal-ip.com.au/sarah-moorfoot) - [Latest News - Intellectual Property News Australia](https://fal-ip.com.au/blog-1) - [Payments](https://fal-ip.com.au/payments-pay-your-invoice-online-to-fal-ip) - [Contact](https://fal-ip.com.au/contact) - [Call Us Now](tel:+61396422252) ![FAL Lawyers Logo](https://fal-ip.com.au/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png) **Melbourne** Level 45, 600 Bourke Street, Melbourne VIC 3000 **Canberra** Level 3, 10 National Circuit, Barton ACT 2600 ### Sitemap - [Home](https://fal-ip.com.au/) - [Services](https://fal-ip.com.au/services) - Service Areas - [Melbourne VIC 3000](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-melbourne-vic-3000) - [Sydney NSW 2000](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-sydney-nsw-2000) - [Brisbane QLD 4000](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-brisbane-qld-4000) - [Adelaide SA 5000](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-adelaide-sa-5000) - [Geelong VIC 3220](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-geelong-vic-3220) - [Ballarat VIC 3350](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-ballarat-vic-3350) - [Canberra VIC 2600](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-canberra-vic-2600) - [Bendigo VIC 3550](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-bendigo-vic-3550) - [Shepparton VIC 3630](https://fal-ip.com.au/intellectual-property-services-in-shepparton-vic-3630) - Mildura VIC 3500 - Wollongong NSW 2500 - [Industries](https://fal-ip.com.au/industries) FAL acknowledges the Traditional Owners of country throughout Australia. We recognise their continuing connection to Country, practices, knowledge systems and communities. We pay our respects to Elders, past and present. [![LinkedIn Icon](https://cdn-icons-png.flaticon.com/512/174/174857.png)](https://au.linkedin.com/company/fal-lawyers) [![Email Icon](https://cdn-icons-png.flaticon.com/512/732/732200.png)](mailto:ip@fal-lawyers.com.au) ©2025 All rights reserved. Website by [Boost Your Brand](https://boostyourbrand.au) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Michelle Wilson", "url" : "https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/author/michelle-wilson" }, "dateModified" : "2025-05-21T06:02:50.289Z", "datePublished" : "2020-06-16T13:50:51.000Z", "headline" : "Kraft v Bega: Trade Dress Dispute Over Peanut Butter | FAL IP Lawyers", "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://fal-ip.com.au/blog/a-nutty-trade-mark-dispute-kraft-v-bega", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://fal-ip.com.au/hubfs/This%20is%20an%20image%20of%20the%20FAL%20IP%20logo%20by%20FAL%20Lawyers.png" }, "name" : "FAL IP" } } ```